Skip to main content

Detainee Representation from Police Questioning to the Detention Hearing

Has a family member been arrested‚ and you do not know where they are or what they are suspected of? Is there a detention hearing tomorrow morning and no one to represent them? Do you want to know whether they can be released to an alternative to detention?

Adv. Adi Peshko Katz is a former criminal prosecutor‚ holds a master's degree in criminal law and adjudication and appears before all courts. Her familiarity with how the police and the prosecution justify detention requests allows her to see quickly what is missing from a request and where it can be challenged.

Representation includes advice before or during questioning‚ appearing at the hearing on extending detention‚ proposing suitable alternatives to detention and filing an appeal when the decision is not justified. Alongside the legal work‚ the office explains to the family what is happening at each stage‚ what they can do and what they had better not do.

In cases connected to a family conflict‚ the office's family law background makes it possible to see the effect of the detention on parallel proceedings as well. The goal in every case is the same: to bring the detainee home as soon as possible and on terms that allow them to live their life and conduct their defence.

Call now‚ and we will act at once to bring the detainee home as quickly as possible.

A phone on a bedside table at night

An arrest almost always comes as a surprise. A phone call from a police station in the middle of the night‚ a partner who did not come home‚ a teenager taken in for questioning‚ and within a few hours the family is facing a system it does not know and a language it does not understand.

The person arrested is cut off from the world‚ does not know what has been said about them or what the suspicions are based on‚ and is under heavy pressure to talk‚ explain and get out quickly. It is precisely in these moments that decisions are made that will shape the entire case: what is said in the first round of questioning‚ whether the suspect is released or stays in custody‚ and on what terms.

A suspect who is released can meet their lawyer freely‚ gather evidence and return to normal life‚ while a detainee builds their defence from a cell. That is why detainee representation is a field where availability‚ decisiveness and knowledge of the system carry decisive weight.

The Rights of a Person Under Arrest

Israeli law gives a detainee basic rights that are worth knowing in advance‚ because under stress it is easy to give them up. A detainee has the right to have a close person and a lawyer notified of the arrest‚ and the right to meet and consult a lawyer.

They are entitled to remain silent‚ and silence during questioning is not an admission‚ although in some cases it may later be used to support other evidence. A detainee who has not been released by the police must be brought before a judge within 24 hours‚ and in exceptional cases defined by law the period is longer.

A detainee without a lawyer is in many cases entitled to representation by the Public Defender's Office in detention proceedings. Still‚ the identity of the lawyer‚ their availability and their knowledge of the case matter‚ and many families prefer to turn to a private lawyer from the first hours. If possible‚ it is better not to sign documents or give a detailed statement before speaking with a lawyer.

Detention for the Purpose of Investigation

When the police want to keep holding a suspect to complete the investigation‚ they ask the Magistrates' Court to extend the detention. At this hearing the judge examines two main questions: whether there is reasonable suspicion that the suspect committed an offence‚ and whether there are grounds for detention‚ such as a risk of obstructing the investigation‚ danger to the public or a risk of flight.

The police present the judge with confidential investigation material that the defence does not see‚ so much of the defence lawyer's work is asking the police representative the right questions and building an argument from what comes out at the hearing. The court may extend detention for limited periods‚ and at each extension the police must show progress in the investigation.

A phone on a bedside table at night

Even when the judge does not order full release‚ it is possible to shorten the extension or set conditions that allow release later. A Magistrates' Court decision can be appealed to the District Court‚ and sometimes it is the appeal that leads to release.

Detention Until the End of Proceedings

When an indictment is filed‚ the prosecution can ask for the defendant to be held in custody until the end of the entire trial. This is a particularly dramatic step‚ since a criminal trial may last months or even years and the defendant conducts it behind bars.

To order such detention‚ the court must be satisfied that there is prima facie evidence of guilt‚ that grounds for detention exist and that the purpose of detention cannot be achieved by a less harmful alternative. At this stage the defence studies the investigation material in depth‚ looking for weaknesses in the evidence‚ contradictions between accounts and flaws in the investigation.

At the same time it prepares a concrete and credible proposal for an alternative to detention. The difference between a detained defendant and a released one also affects the final outcome‚ because a defendant who is free can prepare for trial in better conditions and negotiate from a less pressured position.

Alternatives to Detention and Release Conditions

In most cases the question is not only whether to release‚ but on what terms. The court may release on bail and restrictive conditions‚ such as a cash deposit‚ a third-party guarantee‚ full or partial house arrest‚ an order to stay away from a certain place or person‚ a ban on leaving the country or electronic monitoring.

Sometimes the court asks the Probation Service for a report‚ which assesses the defendant and the proposed supervisors and makes a recommendation. Preparing a good alternative means choosing suitable supervisors who understand the responsibility and can actually carry it‚ and presenting a place of residence that keeps the defendant away from the risk factors the prosecution pointed to.

An alternative that was built seriously is more convincing than a general offer made on the spot‚ and it is often the difference between going home and months in custody. Even after release‚ it is possible to ask for the conditions to be eased once time has passed and circumstances have changed.

Arrests in Conflicts Within the Family

Quite a few arrests happen against the background of complaints within the family‚ often in the middle of a relationship crisis. When a complaint alleging domestic violence is filed‚ the police act fast‚ and often the suspect is arrested before the full picture is clear.

The arrest and the conditions set after it‚ such as removal from the home or a ban on contact with family members‚ directly affect the children‚ the parenting arrangements and other legal proceedings between the partners. In such a situation it is important that the criminal defence and family law considerations are looked at together‚ because agreeing to a particular release condition may affect the case in the family court.

When divorce proceedings are running in parallel‚ coordination between the detention representation and the divorce lawyer prevents mistakes that are hard to correct later. The office's experience in both fields makes it possible to manage both fronts in a coordinated way‚ protecting the suspect's rights and the children's welfare.

When Every Hour Counts

In an arrest‚ time works against the detainee. Every hour without advice is an hour in which they may say things that harm them‚ and every hearing held without preparation is an opportunity that may not come again. The office of Adv. Adi Peshko Katz represents detainees and defendants in detention proceedings from the Krayot and Haifa to courts across the country‚ and helps families understand what is happening and how they can help.

If someone close to you has been arrested or summoned for questioning‚ do not wait for the court hearing to look for a lawyer. Get in touch today and we will work out together the right way to represent them and to seek their release as soon as possible.

Table of contents
  1. The Rights of a Person Under Arrest
  2. Detention for the Purpose of Investigation
  3. Detention Until the End of Proceedings
  4. Alternatives to Detention and Release Conditions
  5. Arrests in Conflicts Within the Family
  6. When Every Hour Counts

More practice areas

Divorce Lawyer

Prenuptial Agreement Lawyer

Expert guides

View all